Menstrual Disc vs. Cup: Which Is Right for You?

Related articles

Back to blog

Menstrual Disc vs. Cup: Which Is Right for You?

Menstrual Disc vs. Cup: Which Is Right for You?

So, you've decided to ditch tampons and pads for something more modern, eco-friendly, and budget-savvy? Smart move! Now, you’re faced with a decision: menstrual disc or menstrual cup? It’s like choosing between two different paths on a hike—both leading to the same destination but with a slightly different journey along the way. So, let’s break it down.

The Menstrual Cup: The Tried-and-True OG

Menstrual cups have been around for quite some time, and for good reason. They’re soft, bell-shaped silicone (or rubber) cups that you fold, insert into your vagina, and use to catch your flow. Here’s why cups have won over many hearts and bodies—and why some women may be looking for alternatives:

Pros:

  1. Long-Lasting Protection: Cups can hold more fluid than tampons and can be worn for up to 12 hours. So, fewer trips to the bathroom!
  2. Eco-Friendly: Unlike tampons, which you toss after every use, menstrual cups are reusable. You can keep one for years if cared for properly.
  3. Budget-Friendly: That initial investment may seem like a splurge, but over time, it’s much more cost-effective. You only need one, and it could last you 5-10 years.
  4. Customizable Fit: Cups come in various sizes and shapes, making it easy for you to find a fit that suits your body and flow for better comfort and effectiveness.

Cons:

  1. Learning Curve: Getting the hang of inserting and removing it can be… let’s say, a bit of a journey. It might take a few tries (and positions, and perhaps a glass of wine) to get comfortable with it.
  2. Size Matters: Cups come in various sizes, so finding the right one for your flow and anatomy can take some experimenting.
  3. Removal Messiness: Cups can be tricky to remove without causing a bit of a spill situation, especially in a public restroom. But hey, practice makes perfect! 
  4. Suction Sensitivity: Cups rely on suction to stay in place, which can feel uncomfortable and be a little challenging to manage.

The Menstrual Disc: The Cool New Kid on the Block

Now let’s talk about the menstrual disc, the younger, slightly edgier cousin of the menstrual cup. Discs are also inserted into the vagina but sit higher up in the vaginal fornix, near the cervix. Instead of a cup, think of it more like a disc that collects blood in a flatter, more laid-back style.

Pros:

  1. Less Pressure, More Comfort: Because of where the disc sits, many women find it more comfortable, especially if they have a low cervix or feel excessive pressure with a menstrual cup.
  2. Mess-Free Sex: Yes, you read that right. The disc can stay in during penetrative sex, which isn’t an option with the cup. That’s a major perk if you want to keep things spontaneous.
  3. Extended Wear Time: Like cups, discs can hold quite a bit of fluid and can be worn for up to 12 hours. 
  4. Disposable or Reusable Options: Unlike cups, discs are available in both reusable and disposable forms, giving you more flexibility based on your preference.

Cons:

  1. More Tricky to Insert: Since they sit higher in the vagina, getting discs in the right spot can be a bit more complicated, especially if you’re new at it. It might take some practice to master proper insertion and positioning.
  2. Leaking During Removal: Sometimes, discs will do their own version of a mic drop during removal—cue the unexpected gush. A little heads-up: this could happen, so be prepared. Some women may find removal messier compared to cups.

Enter Halo Disc Pod: The Game-Changer

But what if I told you there’s a way to enjoy the benefits of both a menstrual disc and a cup without having to choose? Meet Halo Disc Pod—the innovative period product that combines the best of both worlds.

Why Halo Disc Pod Might Be Your New Best Friend:

  • Ultimate Comfort: Halo Disc Pod is designed to sit comfortably and securely, just like a disc, but with the ease of insertion of a cup. Whether you're a first-timer or a seasoned pro, Halo Disc Pod is easy to use, with a fit that feels just right.
  • One Size Fits Most: No need to stress about finding the right size. Halo Disc Pod is designed to comfortably fit most women, making the selection process as simple as it gets.
  • One-Handed Insertion and Pull-Tab Design: Halo Disc Pod is engineered for easy, one-handed insertion, and its pull-tab design ensures smooth, hassle-free removal. No more fumbling—just quick, efficient handling every time.
  • Mess- and Stress-Free: Halo Disc Pod has an advanced anti-leak design that ensures smooth removal without the dreaded spill. Plus, it offers the same mess-free intimacy as a disc, so you can keep your period low-key, even in those intimate moments.
  • Eco-Friendly and Cost-Effective: Like cups and discs, Halo Disc Pods are reusable, making them a sustainable choice for both your body and the environment. Plus, with their long-lasting durability, you save money in the long run—a win for your wallet and the planet!
  • All-Day Confidence: With up to 12 hours of protection, Halo Disc Pod gives you the freedom to go about your day without worrying about frequent changes or leaks. Whether you’re hitting the gym, the office, or the sheets, Halo Disc Pod has got you covered.

Which One Is Right for You?

So, how do you choose between menstrual cups, menstrual discs, or Halo Disc Pods? Here’s a quick guide:

  • Are you comfortable with a learning curve? Cups and discs both require some getting used to, but Halo Disc Pods are designed for intuitive use—perfect for beginners or those looking for a hassle-free experience.
  • Are you looking for mess-free period sex? Both discs and Halo Disc Pods offer this benefit, but Halo Disc Pods provide it with the added ease of worry-free removal.
  • Concerned about removal mess? If spill control is a priority, Halo Disc Pods' advanced design minimizes the mess, making them a great choice for a cleaner experience.
  • Do you have a low cervix or experience excessive pressure with cups? Halo Disc Pods are engineered for comfort across different anatomies, offering a snug, irritation-free fit.
  • Are you environmentally conscious? Cups, discs, and Halo Disc Pods all make excellent eco-friendly choices, but Halo Disc Pods stand out for combining sustainability with superior comfort and functionality.

Final Thoughts

Choosing between a menstrual cup, disc, or Halo Disc Pod ultimately comes down to what works best for your body and lifestyle. Whether you’re drawn to the familiarity of a cup, the innovative design of a disc, or the all-in-one versatility of Halo Disc Pods, you’re making a choice that’s better for your body, the environment, and your wallet.

So go ahead—try one (or all three!) and find your perfect period partner. With Halo Disc Pods in the mix, your options have never been better. You’ve got this!

Related articles